Is corporal punishment necessary to discipline

What if the belt leaves a bruise that lasts for a few days?

Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Essay Sample

In reading and researching this particular topic, I realized that many of the sources dealing with corporal punishment always mention paddles, rulers, straps and other items being used. However, it must be noted that a child who receives a couple of spankings will more than likely not cause them to become bullies, thieves or repeat criminals.

There is the natural consequence in which the discipline naturally occurs as a result of the childs behavior i. My wife at the time was not an easy person to reason with and she had no patience with the boys so I was the one that initiated a good deal of the discipline.

In todays world, taking a cell phone or game system away from an older child 12 16 is like taking their world from them.

Corporal punishment in the home

On 1 JulySweden became the world's first nation to explicitly ban corporal punishment of children through an amendment to the Parenthood and Guardianship Code which stated: These can be tough questions. For some kinds of criminal behavior, I think we'd benefit from having punishment along the lines of Singapore's caning as a part of our judicial system.

In many cases of so-called 'bad behavior', the child is simply responding in the only way he can, given his age and experience, to neglect of basic needs. Canada allows spanking by parents or legal guardians only. One end of this spectrum is clearly accepted as physical abuse by rational people while much of the rest of it is not, which is a big part of what makes this such a touchy subject.

Why not start using effective discipline methods when the child is young?

Corporal Punishment in the Home: Parenting Tool or Parenting Fail…

However, the proportion of suspects who are in their twenties, and therefore raised in a no-smacking culture, has decreased sinceas has the proportion born in the Nordic nations with corporal punishment bans.

As a result of her research and documented in her writings, Cope states, The goal of discipline, whatever the method, is to set reasonable limits that protect children from harm and teach them what is safe, right, and acceptable.

For example, if the child doesn't eat, he will get hungry. There have been few longitudinal studies and, as you can probably imagine, there are a number of potentially confounding socioeconomic and caregiver variables.

For instance, a tree year old child who runs in the road will learn quicker from a butt smack than receiving a prize for remaining on the sidewalk. There should be communication with the child explaining the spanking and why their action was inappropriate.

According to Gershoff, the intent of such bans on corporal punishment is not typically to prosecute parents, but to set a higher social standard for caregiving of children.

They are about three years apart so there was always some fighting among them. Many researchers believe that corporal punishment leads to children eventually becoming adult abusers. White boys were subjected to this cruelty as it was thought that it would make them manlier and the process would pass down it to their children as a form of discipline.

Reward and punishment teaches the child to be "good" as long as we are looking. They are mad at their husband or wife and take it out on the child. Studies of parents that do administer spankings have shown that most of the spankings that are handed out happen after p.

Slowly, though, more and more parents voluntarily refrained from its use and corporal punishment was prohibited throughout the educational system in ".

Debate: Corporal punishment of children

Many pro corporal punishment researchers believe that research data related to corporal punishment is imperfect due to the fact that the studies do not distinguish between the different types physical discipline i.

We have seen some of the pros of corporal punishment, but what about the cons. At the same time, "punishment" in the traditional sense does not always have the intended effect. In essence, corporal punishment supporters share that after other disciplinary actions have not worked, a good alternative is spanking.

The recognition and reporting of physical abuse is hindered by the lack of uniform or clear definitions.

Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Essay Sample

It is not possible logically to differentiate between a smack and a physical assault since both are forms of violence. Harsh physical punishment and verbal abuse can never be justified as ways to discipline children. By the s, the gap between belief and practice had nearly disappeared, with slightly more than 10 percent of parents reporting that they use corporal punishment.

The defence is ultimately derived from English law. The age of discipline the relevance of age to the reasonableness of corporal punishment. Todays Parent, 28, Is punishment necessary?

Is Corporal Punishment Necessary To Discipline Children

Ask Question. Disclaimer: I assume you mean "punishment" not as in "corporal punishment" (which is, as torbengb pointed out, illegal in many countries) Punishment and Discipline is absolutely necesary for a child to grow up healthy and well balanced. The type of punishment, however, varies greatly.

If deprived of disciplinary spanking, even the most prepared parent is merely left with nagging, begging, negotiating, or yelling, and certainly without the position of authority needed to. ntroduction to PsychologyInstructor Stephanie Anderson September 8, Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Is corporal punishment considered to be an effective form of discipline for children We have all been privy to occurrences of corporal punishment to discipline children a mother smacking her child to control a.

Nov 01,  · Pediatricians are a source of advice for parents and guardians concerning the management of child behavior, including discipline strategies that are used to teach appropriate behavior and protect their children and others from the adverse effects of challenging behavior.

Aversive disciplinary strategies, including all forms of corporal punishment and yelling at or shaming children. Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Essay Sample. ntroduction to PsychologyInstructor Stephanie Anderson September 8, Is Corporal Punishment Necessary to Discipline Children Is corporal punishment considered to be an effective form of discipline for children We have all been privy to occurrences of corporal punishment to discipline.

There is a difference between corporal punishment and child abuse. Corporal punishment is designed to punish specific acts of significant misbehavior and delinquency.

It is not a wanton and unreasonable act of violence. Child abuse, on the contrary, is the unjustified and unreasoned beating of children.

Is corporal punishment necessary to discipline
Rated 5/5 based on 19 review